Tensions Remain Hot between Councilman, Fire Officials
Charles Packard says Susquehanna Hose Company leadership awaits apology from councilman after perceived slights towards fire chief and deputy chief.
Susquehanna Hose Company President Charles Packard spoke for 18 minutes in front of City Council Monday. But his comments could have been just as easily directed at one person on the six-man council.
Packard's words were the most intense of the one-hour, 44-minute meeting, as he used the public comment period as an opportunity to address recent discord between the Hose Company and Councilman Jim Miller.
Miller recently said during Public Safety Commission meetings, and on Patch, that the department was "a sacred cow" and suggested its leaders purchase paint and personally apply it to the hydrants they wanted the city to mark.
The Hose Company has since removed itself from the Public Safety Commission—which is chaired by Miller—and is reporting directly to Mayor Wayne H. Dougherty.
Packard spoke to the council on Monday to tell them the Hose Company will continue to abstain from the commission meetings.
"On this occasion, I assure you, I speak for all dedicated members of the Hose Company," Packard said. "You, Mr. Miller, have failed us. You have failed to do your job and you have failed to provide the leadership this city deserves."
Miller, who made no rebuttal to the public commentary, is a lifetime member of the Hose Company.
Packard ended his statement by requesting Miller publicly apologize to Susquehanna Hose Company Chief Scott Hurst and to Deputy Chief Chad Packard.
After the meeting adjourned, Miller told Packard he would be issuing a response in the near future.
Hurst also spoke Monday and presented statistics about the pressing concerns that the Hose Company had laid out to the Public Safety Commission over the last seven months.
Hurst outlined a need for markers to be placed on hydrants so firefighters could find them in heavy snow. He also requested the city paint any unmarked fire hydrants, particularly those in Bulle Rock. Also, the fire company wants the city to relocate a mailbox on Grace Manor Drive that is blocking a hydrant. Finally, Hurst reiterated the need for the council to pass a pending ordinance to mandate carbon monoxide detectors in all city homes.
Hurst told the council that he made the decision to leave the commission because its meetings had become "non-productive."
"We've got better things to do at home with our families," Hurst said. "I'm not going to subject the deputy chief to that. We don't get paid to go to these meetings."
Chad Packard, the son of Charles Packard, was the Hose Company's representative at the Public Safety Commission for 10 years. He left the Nov. 4 meeting feeling "humiliated" by Miller's suggestions that the Hose Company paint their own hydrants and shovel them out themselves during snowstorms.
Upon Packard's decision to leave that meeting, Miller suggested Packard was simply "taking his ball and going home."
The elder Packard took issue with those comments Monday.
"That comment is shameful," Charles Packard said. "You should be thankful that the hose company has never, never left a job unfinished. We never take our ball and go home."
The meeting was adjourned one minute after Packard stopped speaking. He handed over an eight-page letter, which was used as a reference for his presentation, to be entered into record.
The Hose Company is planning to meet with Mayor Dougherty next week. But company members told Patch that their leaders' actions have already begun to reap results.
The hydrant markers are scheduled for delivery this week, and the paint is to be applied to the hydrants in Bulle Rock by spring.
The Grace Manor Drive mailbox is scheduled to be moved.
An ordinance concerning the mandate of carbon monoxide detectors in all city residences is likely to appear before City Council within the next month.
HDG Citizen
9:35 am on Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Although the SHCO is an important aspect of HDG can someone please let them know they don’t run the City and to air their dirty laundry behind closed doors. The SHCO is nothing but a man's club supported by the taxpayer. Why does a town the size of HDG need 5 firehouses in better shape than our local schools? If SHCO was truly concerned about the citizens they would give funds back from the tax payer allocation to fund CO detectors for the City, painting of the hydrants, and hydrant markers. Building new firehouses and purchasing pretty new engines is not the best way for the City’s money to be spent.
SHAWN HURST
10:01 am on Tuesday, November 16, 2010
HDG Citizen I have some question's for you:
Do you know how much a fire line pumper cost?
The price for a ladder/tower truck?
Do you understand why we have 5 staions?
Do you know how much it cost for one set of firefighters gear?
Do you know how much money the SHCO is saving tax payers each year?
Do you know how many times the firefighters in HdG get out of bed each night, leaves the dinner table, misses our kids birthday parties, and sometimes miss holidays?
What is the average response time for a piece of fire equipment to arrive at your house after you call 911?
I'm sure you can not answer any of these question. Tuesday night is the fire company training night. Members we be at each station to answer my questions for you. Please don't bash the people in this town that could some day save your life or a family member. We can always use the help. So why don't you come out tonight and get a application to join one of the best fire companies in the state. You may change your mind.
Hollee Sifford
11:19 am on Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Like I commented....With all this SHCO DRAMA has anyone took the time to read about the EDUCATOR OF THE WEEK..OR WARRIOR OF THE WEEK?Two very important stories about people in our community.HavreDeGrace has ALOT of GRREAT PEOPLE...LIKE Mr."W" and our young students!!!!!!I am VERY proud to be a member of this community and even prouder to be an employee of the school.So people take the the time to read ALL the PATCH has to offer and not JUST the drama....Did you know that the High School has a ARTS FESTIVAL or that THE HDG WARRIORS have yet ANOTHER important game this week???OR....That some of OUR lcal businesses have alot to offer? That the RELAY FOR LIFE is gearing up for another GREAT RELAY? OR....are you just stuck in the drama????OH and by the way.....HAVE A GREAT WEEK!!!!!
Gretchin Wilson
11:29 am on Tuesday, November 16, 2010
I read all those articles too! And i fully plan on being at the game friday night to support our mighty Warriors! I just find the attacks wrong and feel the need to chime in. All-in-all, this IS a great community, and yes, some people are just stuck on themselves, AND thrive on the drama.
Only the Lonely
12:57 pm on Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Well Mr.Hurst ,
Thank You for all you do for the community, It is a very important thing,It is a service that we need in the community, That you stick to your guns on this issue, as we have and will continue to support your fire companys, It is a shame, When I first started hearing about the flags, Well that is an important issue that is a no brainer for safety, The hydrants painted, What is wrong with this picture, These are very important things in the safety of all involved in Havre De Grace or for anywhere for that matter. Safety should be the first important thing that needs to be addressed on all aspects.
HDG Citizen
1:08 pm on Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Scott your right I'm not aware. But since you have raised the questions please provide the answers so the public is aware. Maybe the patch can provide an article of the company’s revenues and expenses or make the company's budget public.
I am fully appreciative of the service your members provide the City. You risk your lives and forfeit personal time that’s a known fact. But I happened to be at the meeting in which this issue started. The comments made by the SHCO Chief were inappropriate. If the City was dropping the ball then speak to those off the record don’t throw stones in the public. Obviously, there was miscommunication as is apparent by Councilman Miller and the Police Chief not being aware of the issues raised previously at the PSC. Many fires have been fought without painted hydrants, CO detectors, or hydrant markers; the solutions are simple.
Instead of continuing to throw stones turn this into a positive. Offer ways to solve the issues identified. Recruit service groups from HDGHS, the Lions Club, Boy Scouts to paint hydrates, install CO detectors and hydrant markers. Offer $10,000 from the SHCO’s budget to fund the expenses. Show the public it is about the citizens and not grandstanding on the Council floor. Show the SHCO can receive criticism and react in a professional manner.
Ben Michalski
11:09 pm on Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Kudos to you citizen!
SHAWN HURST
7:43 am on Wednesday, November 17, 2010
HDG Citizen
I would like to clear up your statement about " behind closed doors" . The mentioned items the fire company was requesting were brought to the Public Safety Committee back in July of this year. The committee chair did not act on any of those items. At that time they were requested "behind closed door" . The fire Chief brought it to the city council and the mayor when it was not being taken care of. All the minutes from the Public Safety Committee were pulled from the last several months and were turned it to the city for record. In those minutes it shows that all the requests made by the SHCO. I'm sorry you are on one of those few that thinks the SHCO is in the wrong. BUT, its our job to keep the people of this city safe.
If the fire Chief makes a stong stand for anything I assure you its not just for some stupid reason. Its very true....this company will fight to the end for something we feel is very important for our citizens we protect.
I'm pretty sure if the outcome of our last snowstorm, a fire in Bulle Rock with a unmarked hydrant, or a CO detector call would have resulted in a death some people would be asking why didn't the fire company do something. Well now we are and I have to tell you it amazes me that some people would complain about it. A few weeks back the SHCO went door to door on Union Ave to pass out free smoke detectors. This was after the fatal fire we had. I read a comment form a citizen that said " Its a little to late for that now".
SHAWN HURST
7:48 am on Wednesday, November 17, 2010
So you see we are damed if we do and damed if we don't. Like I said I'm really sorry some of you think the SHCO is the bad guy. But, when we request things it is ALWAYS for the safety of our citizens. You can also rest assured that when ever someone in this city needs help and they call 911 we will be there within a couple of minutes and that will never change. The Susquehanna Hose Comapany has been dedicated to this city for over 100 years. So please stop bashing the Hose company and thank us for the job we do or please don't say anything.
Lt. Shawn Hurst
Susquehanna Hose Company
Karen Shafer
6:54 pm on Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Ahhh ... so familiar ... brings me back to the days of the HDG HOA ... going to EVERY single council meeting to make our point. As a former lifelong HDG resident ... I for one ... appreciate the volunteers who risk life and limb to protect HDG!!!! They are the ones, in fact, who saved my entire family from carbon monoxide ... while no longer an HDG resident ... I would happily suggest planting several shovels in Councilman Miller's front yard.
Ben Michalski
10:34 pm on Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Kudos and accolades to Charley Packerd and Fire Chief Hurst for standing up for their convictions. IMHO these two men are a credit to the city. Gentleman,I applaud you. As to the
colloquial "Havre de Grace Finest" you have defined the term.
As to Mr. Millers comments to these gentleman, politics, the past and good governing do not nessassarly make for good partners. Things can be said that unfortunately can't be taken back. I know this only too well. In the consturction trades we have a saying...:Measure twice and cut once. This can be applied to life....Think twice and talk once. Now that feelings have been hurt, and jaws dropped to the floor, it's time to move forward and resist the temtation to vindiction, posturing and ill will.
I will also say that Mr. Miller may have been having an off day...something we are all entitled to as being human. However my past experience with Mr. Miller has been a positive one and I can say that again...IMHO he has been a dedicated and staunch leader and city advocate. All B/S aside it is time to mend positions and move forward.
In these adverse and trying times none of us can afford disfunction and resentment. Let's move on, accept accountability and consiquence and always...ALWAYS... keep in mind. Most of teach best what we most need to learn...I myself am a living testiment to that maxim.
Gretchin Wilson
11:01 pm on Tuesday, November 16, 2010
I think your comment is very well put!
Ben Michalski
11:19 pm on Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Thank you mam....I just feeling a tad magnanimous at the time :)
Ben Michalski
11:16 pm on Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Please excuse more of my polemic diatribe but we the citizens depend on the COLLECTIVE AND MUTUAL dedications of our elected leaders to be insightful, magnanimous and when ego affords...humble. WOW! place our ego aside...what a challange even to the most humble of us.
Citizens..take it from me....nothing comes from conflict but MORE CONFLICT. Hold fast your words...they can come back with a vengeance. Accountability and transparency in governing is a gift to a chosen few leaders. A Courage of Conviction is endemic only to a chosen few..but it can be acquired with diligence, persistence and desire. It is a virtue that once inculcated can raise a mind to heights that can move mountains and send the most unlearned to the halls of legacy however ignored can take the most learned to the pits of despair.
Let us all put aside our differences and focus on our similarities...the end result will be an esprit de corp and sense of honor that can... if cultivated...CHANGE OUR COLLECTIVE LIVES AND REVITALIZE A CITY.
Craig Triplett
12:59 am on Wednesday, November 17, 2010
HDG Citizen, I think you are misunderstood. You are correct in saying “Many fires have been fought without painted hydrants, CO detectors, or hydrant markers”. However there are many behind the scenes tactics that come into play revolving around the issues you speak of.
The SHCo is not asking for the hydrants to be painted so they look nice. The colors are used to determine the amount of water flow from any given hydrant. The city has someone painting the hydrants every day until all are complete. What they have been asking for is to make the unpainted hydrants a priority as some just have old paint and they are still able tell what color the hydrants are. In addition the hydrants in question are in an area where there are very large houses to protect in the event of a fire and the water flow will be a major factor contributing to the fire loss.
Craig Triplett
1:00 am on Wednesday, November 17, 2010
In reference to the flags, I think everyone remembers the accumulations of snow we had last winter. Finding the hydrants was a near impossible task for weeks on end. No one is asking the city to shovel the hydrants one by one. Everyone fully understands that that would be an unreasonable request. It’s not unreasonable to ask for the flags that attach to the hydrants, surrounding jurisdictions use them including Harford County. As to the cost, The Chief researched and found acceptable flags for a dollar or two a piece. This has been requested for months now and with the cold weather moving closer it is becoming a pressing issue.
Co detectors should be self explanatory. Much like smoke detectors, they don’t help us, they help you and every other citizen in Havre de Grace. Once again with the cold weather moving closer they are a more pressing issue as many Co incidents are due to a malfunctioning furnace.
All of these requests are being made with only the safety of the citizens of Havre de Grace in mind. I can assure you it is not to boost anyone's personal agenda.
Tom Phelan
11:52 pm on Sunday, November 21, 2010
I wish the Patch would require respondents to reveal themselves. Citizens should know when stupidity resides on their block.
Marsha Tarbert
10:53 am on Tuesday, November 23, 2010
Oh dear God. This reminds me of why I left Haddy Grace. I have known Jim Miller all his life. If he thinks maybe the SHCO should pay for or do the work they are demanding be done so be it. There is a recession on, remember? The days of Big Daddy Govt are over. I noticed that when Baltimore Co and Baltimore City moved to HdG they were going to demand money for stuff. Did you think to ask Clark Turner who made a gazillion dollars on Bulle Rock to paint the damn hydrants? What's wrong with the Hose Co having members REMEMBER where they are????? It seems to me that worked in town for a hundred years.
Ben Michalski
9:26 pm on Tuesday, November 23, 2010
I agree marsha, the roles in this sonnet do go both ways and snow has been around for more than a 100 years....however "clarkie"...(isn't that a cute diminutive for everyone who wants to be a "clarkie pal"?) in my humble opinion and while doing what most self centered ego developers do well, has bled HdG for all it was worth. He's off to more furtile hunting grounds where the fire hydrants will be new and improved however I don't think he has a dog in this fight.
Sean Welsh
10:18 pm on Tuesday, November 23, 2010
Ben — Good idea. I've been shown maps in existence, but they only show an approximate location on a parcel. If a property is 100 feet wide at the street, you may be able to estimate its within a 50-foot area. I think the goal is to minimize searching in the event of significant snowfall, as well as to indicate the locations of the hydrants so plows don't damage them.
Morality, What?
3:07 pm on Wednesday, November 24, 2010
Congrats Jason, you are the straw that broke the camel's back. You've all made it pretty clear that I CANNOT have an opinion unless I put my name out there publicly for people who have been threatening and aggressive on here. So I'm deleting my comments and if at all possible, my account as well. Happy Thanksgiving.
Kathy Keen
11:25 am on Sunday, November 28, 2010
The spokespeople of the Susquehanna Hose Company are acting like oversensitive cry-babies over a few negative comments by Jim Miller. I'm sick of hearing about it. Their overreaction is proving Jim Miller's point about the Company being a 'sacred cow' in Havre de Grace. Don't anyone dare criticize them!
Bob Slede
12:00 pm on Sunday, November 28, 2010
Well Ms. Keen you are another citizen thats has not one clue as to whats going on. You say its "overreactions" the Hose Company calls it keeping citizens safe. And from your comments you would be the first to complain if something happend to one of your loved ones from one of these things not being addressed. If you don't like the Hose Company for what they stand for why don't you move out of town where it could take anywhere from 5-20 minutes to get a fire truck to your house. There is no other fire company in the county or even the state that gets the fire protection the citizens of HDG recieve.
Final thought: if you are tired of hearing about things, go to the next city council meeting and tell everyone you don't like what the fire dept. stands for. Because I'M SICK of hearing people like you in this town complaing about the fire dept. The only point Jim Miller has proved is he doesn't care about the citizens of hdg. He proved that when he failed to let the fire company know there was a water pressure issue in Bulle Rock. Please know you facts before you come on here trying to make a point!!!
Biller's Bikes
3:52 pm on Sunday, November 28, 2010
Bob Slede. Use your real name.
Craig Triplett
12:03 am on Monday, November 29, 2010
Mrs. Keen, if you’re sick of hearing about it stop reading it. No one is forcing you. It’s very easy for people similar to yourself to sit back and say what you say when you’re not the one who gets up at 3 or 4 in the morning to get on a fire engine on the road only to get home just in time to get dressed to go to work and read the negative comments written by a few know it alls. I’m sure you and most citizens sleep well at night with very little distractions knowing that if your house catches fire, you have upwards of the best fire protection in the country. You’re probably the type person who makes complaints about the fire truck blowing the siren too loud and disturbing your sleep. A little oversensitive, maybe so. But I’m sure it’s because we have people like Mr. Miller who like to comment publicly, not to mention blatantly lye about issues that he has dropped the ball on.
Joe Conaway
5:38 pm on Tuesday, November 30, 2010
Mr. Triplett,
I don't believe Mrs. Keen was being critical in any way to SHCO's abilities. She simply stated that some of members of the SHCO were being "oversensitive cry babies". I believe you are being a little too harsh and critical. You stated in your last comment directed at Mrs. Keen, that "no one is forcing you" and "stop reading it". Well, no one is "forcing you" to get up at 3 or 4 in the morning to get on a fire engine and get home just in time to go to work. You did volunteer to become a fireman, correct?
Craig Triplett
12:03 am on Monday, November 29, 2010
. Jimmy can make the comments he does because much like you he is not getting up out of bed and riding a fire engine, nor has he ever shoveled a hydrant out with 3 inches much less 3 feet of snow in front of it. After the comments that I have heard him make (and yes first hand) I don’t think he even has a simple understanding of how a hydrant works. I personally don’t think you or any of the others that have commented negatively towards us have any idea what you are talking about, However you and anyone in town are more than welcome to come and join. We are always looking for new people. But before you put your 2 cents in, you need to be ready to leave your cozy bed and go without your precious sleep not to mention your warm dinners and your beloved holiday’s celebrations, because the reality of the situation is that when the whistle sounds, a fire engine is on location within minutes in this town.
Craig Triplett
Lieutenant Division Number 4
Terran Miller
5:59 pm on Wednesday, December 1, 2010
"Jimmy can make the comments he does because much like you he is not getting up out of bed and riding a fire engine, nor has he ever shoveled a hydrant out with 3 inches much less 3 feet of snow in front of it."
Wow... really Craig? No, my father doesnt get up in the middle of the night anymore, because he is now a lifetime member, putting in his required years in the Fire Department... since he was 18, might I add. I have VERY clear memories of when I was little, my father leaving the house at ALL HOURS of the night in ALL SEASONS to run fire calls. So maybe YOU should look at the facts before you "blatantly lie" about something. Knock it off with the personal attacks and work like adults to get the situation resolved.
Marsha Tarbert
5:07 am on Monday, November 29, 2010
As the granddaughter of a Past President of the Susquehanna Hose Company, I feel I have a dog in this hunt even though I no longer live in town. WHAT HAPPENED TO THE SHCO??????? My God, I haven't heard this much whining since the Mr Frosty truck stopped coming around. OK, the Hose Co has a problem with Jimmy Miller. Why don't you boys just lay them out on the table so we can measure em? And quit telling us how hard you work keeping the citizens safe. If you volunteer to do something, just do it and quit reminding us. We know what you do and show our appreciation with donations or a simple "Job well done." Expecting more is not in the spirit of volunteerism, and maybe you should occupy your time doing something else.
And another thing, WHO ARE YOU TO DEMAND ANYONE BUY A PRODUCT I.E. A CO DETECTOR?????? Last time I checked the Constitution, governments are not allowed to do that. Did you get emblazoned by Øbummer's illegal Health Care Bill? If you pass this ordinance, who is going to go in the house to check if it is there? Ever heard of the 4th Amendment about unreasonable searches? Is a judge going to sign on every search warrant needed to go into people's homes to see if they have a detector? Or is Big Govt HdG going to GIVE everyone a CO detector? Honestly, where have your friggin brains gone?????
martha may
8:14 am on Tuesday, November 30, 2010
Marsha,Marsha, Marsha..... don't get your Brady's in a Bunch. Chill out, this too will pass like the swine flu.
betty coakley
1:09 pm on Monday, November 29, 2010
For you newcomers ----this is not the first time there has been a problem between Mr. Miller and the very admirable members of the SHCO. Just go back about ten years. That was a really nasty mess.
Mike Tarbert
9:31 am on Monday, January 24, 2011
A few years ago there was a building on Pennington st that had a graffiti problem. The resourse officer for the Police dept got the paint and volunteers from the High School did the work. They did a nice job and no one fought. Does this sound like an idea?